In Canada, a go to to heal wounds and restore hope

Pope Francis and Chief Wilton Littlechild say farewell to one another July 29, 2022, in Iqaluit, Nunavut, because the pope prepares to return to the Vatican after a six-day go to. Littlechild, a 78-year-old lawyer, survivor of abuse in a residential faculty and former grand chief of the Confederacy of Treaty Six First Nations, had lobbied onerous for the pope to go to Canada and apologize to residential faculty survivors. (CNS picture/Vatican Media)


What can soften a coronary heart, and what can harden it? St. Augustine mentioned that the identical stirring gesture will coax a noxious stench out of sewage and a wonderful perfume from fragrance; in the identical manner, the identical gesture can soften one particular person and alienate one other. The pope’s latest go to to Canada was proof of this.

Some context: For over a century, the Canadian authorities had a coverage of taking Indigenous youngsters from their households and placing them in boarding faculties the place they have been usually forbidden to go to their folks or communicate their native languages, with the objective being to “civilize” them by instructing them English and the tradition of the settlers. As a result of they have been cheap, and already had expertise working mission faculties, church buildings and spiritual orders, significantly Catholic ones, have been recruited to run these faculties. Whereas there are examples of real schooling and care going down at residential faculties, too lots of them have been characterised by bodily and sexual abuse of the youngsters who have been trapped inside their partitions. The dangerous results of this nonetheless reverberate amongst Canada’s First Nations to at the present time.

Within the Nineteen Nineties, Chief Phil Fontaine, a residential faculty survivor, did necessary work elevating consciousness about what passed off underneath this program. This led to the work of the Reality and Reconciliation Fee, led by commissioners comparable to Chief Wilton Littlechild, one other survivor. The TRC, because it was recognized, produced complete experiences in regards to the historical past of residential faculties and issued calls to motion because of their findings. Certainly one of these was for Pope Francis to come back onto Canadian soil and apologize for the Church’s function within the faculties.

In July, the Holy Father answered this name after receiving a delegation of Indigenous Canadians in Rome 4 months earlier. When this “penitential pilgrimage,” as he known as it, was introduced, a graphic designer of Metis heritage (that’s to say, a descendant of European and Indigenous unions) designed a brand for the go to, a swirling blue circle filled with Aboriginal and papal symbolism. In the event you lived wherever the pope visited, you seemingly noticed that brand in every single place.

Throughout his temporary go to, the pope did an excessive amount of to even start to elucidate right here. Nevertheless, we are able to give attention to just a few particularly important moments.

A heartfelt apology

He first landed in Alberta (which is at present ruled by a Catholic premier) and attended an Indigenous ceremony on the positioning of Ermineskin Indian Residential Faculty, the place he reiterated the apology he had beforehand provided on the Vatican: He was “deeply sorry” for the Church’s participation within the residential faculty program. In a powerfully symbolic gesture, he kissed a banner on which have been written the names of all the youngsters who disappeared at residential faculties — who seemingly died from ill-care however have been by no means returned to their households. (Whether or not or not a specific web site in Kamloops occurs to be an instance of an unmarked graveyard is just not particularly necessary to the truth that such unmarked graveyards undoubtedly exist.)

That is what the pope apologized for. Regardless of what some slanderous commentators declare, he was not apologizing for the evangelistic work of the Church, and even for each single residential faculty; he even acknowledged that “Christian charity was not absent, and there have been many excellent situations of devotion and care for kids.” Nevertheless, it can’t be denied that grave and grotesque harms additionally occurred there, usually perpetuated by clergymen and nuns. This appears to warrant an apology.

At this ceremony, Chief Littlechild of the TRC gave the Holy Father a headdress. For First Peoples, it is a sacred vestment, awarded for necessary work on behalf of the group. The traditionalists who’re snickeringly indignant that the pope donned this headgear can mirror on the truth that some non-Catholic Indigenous folks really feel the identical manner, together with a lady named Si Pih Ko, who rebuked him aloud in Cree. Unusual bedfellows, as they are saying. (Word that none of her protests, which asserted the rights of Indigenous sovereignty, really contradicted the pope’s phrases or actions.)

Pope Francis then met with survivors and spoke at a ceremony in Sacred Coronary heart Church of the First Peoples, a wonderful parish in downtown Edmonton that blends Indigenous spirituality with Catholicism. Francis’ remarks should be fastidiously studied for the methods they drew from the symbolism in that constructing — for instance, the 4 factors of the medication wheel comparable to the cross, or the teepee-shaped tabernacle that he likened to the Hebrew “tent of assembly” — as materials for future reflections on liturgy and iconography. (Considerably, this parish is run by the Oblates, the identical order that ran a majority of Catholic residential faculties and that just lately opened their archives to the Nationwide Heart for Reality and Reconciliation; so much has modified since these uglier days.)

Critics communicate out

Most likely probably the most controversial a part of the journey was the pope’s open-air Mass in Edmonton’s Commonwealth Stadium, which is often used for occasions comparable to soccer video games or monster truck rallies (certainly one of which passed off just a few days after the Mass). Critics claimed that the liturgy lacked Aboriginal content material, they usually have been particularly prickly about the truth that the Eucharistic Prayer was mentioned in Latin. None of them appeared conscious that the pope’s vestments have been designed by a member of the Nisga’a Nation who used Indigenous imagery in it, or {that a} Cree-Metis priest organized the liturgy, and none of them talked about that the Mass was preceded by a speech from at least Phil Fontaine himself, who known as on his Aboriginal brothers and sisters to forgive in an effort to obtain reconciliation and transfer ahead.

There have been additionally complaints in regards to the homily. The Mass celebrated the feast of Sts. Joachim and Anne, and, in line with this, Pope Francis spoke about the necessity to honor our grandparents and preserve the religion they handed on to us with out falling into traditionalism. Many claimed this was insensitive to Indigenous peoples who had been robbed of the expertise of being raised by their grandparents and receiving their tradition.

However this criticism fails to know that this Mass was not meant to be an remoted occasion. Just like the liturgies of the Triduum, it was only one half of a bigger sequence and must be understood in connection to what got here earlier than and afterwards — particularly afterwards, since, that afternoon, he visited Lac St. Anne.

This lake was revered by the Nakota Sioux and Cree nations because the “lake of the Spirit” or “God’s lake” even earlier than Europeans arrived. When Catholic missionaries got here, they quickly acknowledged that those that immersed themselves in its waters usually skilled miraculous healings. They quickly named it after St. Anne, to whom many Indigenous Catholics have a particular devotion, and started organizing pilgrimages there on her feast day. To at the present time, that pilgrimage stays the biggest gathering of First Peoples in western Canada.

When the pope mentioned Mass at this Lourdes of the North, he opened with a greeting in Cree, Nakota and Blackfoot, and addressed precisely this level throughout his sermon, acknowledging that “a part of the painful legacy we at the moment are confronting stems from the truth that Indigenous grandmothers have been prevented from passing on the Religion in their very own language and tradition. That loss was actually tragic, however,” he added, “your presence here’s a testimony of resilience and a recent begin, of pilgrimage towards therapeutic, of a coronary heart open to God who heals the lifetime of communities.” Earlier than he left, the pope, nonetheless in his wheelchair, went all the way down to the lake itself and blessed its waters, having in contrast them in his homily to the Sea of Galilee the place Jesus healed souls and our bodies.

A temper of hopefulness

After leaving Alberta, the pope mentioned Mass and met with Indigenous delegates in Quebec, the place he did for Canadian tradition what he had finished for Indigenous spirituality: Drew fruitful connections between its iconography and Catholic spirituality. The maple leaf is just not precisely wealthy in symbolism for many Canadians, however the Holy Father drew that means from how every maple leaf is exclusive, how every one produces oxygen and the way they can be utilized to bandage and sooth wounds to provide a wonderful exegesis of the Canada flag, which ought to give each Canadian Catholic trigger for patriotic sentiment.

Lastly, Pope Francis concluded his go to within the territory of Nunavut, the place he spoke not solely to residential faculty survivors and elders but in addition to Inuit younger folks exterior of Nakasuk Elementary Faculty. In a way, this was probably the most hanging second of the entire tour. The residential faculties tried to rob Indigenous folks of their tradition and their future. In distinction, right here the pope stood in entrance of a major faculty, used the picture of a standard Inuit lamp in his speech, and exhorted Inuit youths to greatness by quoting to them the Inuit Qaujimajatuqangit ideas, that are the foundations of Inuit cultural pedagogy. A stronger image of the reversal of the residential faculties could be onerous to think about. He concluded his speech by expressing the hope that his hearers would “come to see the Inuk face of Jesus Christ.”

In any case this, what can we are saying? Clearly, the work of restitution for residential faculties is just not over, however this looks like maybe a very powerful milestone in that journey. Some folks, of each a “conservative” and a “progressive” bent, will nonetheless be sad. However for what it’s price, my expertise was that the overall temper was certainly one of solemn however jubilant hopefulness. Some sad tears have been shed, however so have been many grateful and joyful ones; for all of the objections and anger, real therapeutic and restoration occurred. Some hearts have been hardened, however I believe many have been softened, and, out of this tear-soaked clay, we hope and pray that God molds us right into a holier and happier group.

Brett Fawcett writes from Canada.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.